Research · Nov 9, 2026
Do Crypto Index Funds Beat Bitcoin? 2018–2026 Data
Alex· Research Analyst at Cryptoindex AIResearchBitcoinIndex funds
Bitcoin beat the biggest crypto index in 7 of 8 years. The one exception was 2021.
THE ANSWER
No. From 2018 through 2025 bitcoin beat the oldest live crypto index, the Bitwise 10 Large Cap, in 7 of 8 calendar years. $10,000 put into bitcoin at the end of 2017 was worth $62,455 eight years later. The same $10,000 in the index was worth $33,016, and $28,329 in the fund that tracks it.
Key findings
- 7 of 8. Bitcoin outperformed the Bitwise 10 Large Cap Crypto Index in every full calendar year from 2018 to 2025 except 2021.
- 25.7% vs 16.1% a year. That is the compound annual return of bitcoin and of the index over those eight years. The fund's NAV compounded at 13.9%.
- No cushion on the way down. In all three losing years (2018, 2022, 2025) the ten-asset basket fell further than bitcoin alone.
- No good entry year. Pick any January from 2018 to 2025, hold to 30 September 2026, and bitcoin still comes out ahead.
- The basket is mostly bitcoin anyway. BTC was 76.25% of the index on 31 August 2026. The bottom six assets together were 2.26%.
- Fees and discounts made it worse. The fund's NAV trailed its own index by 3.6 percentage points a year on average, and its shares traded at an average 16.43% discount to NAV between December 2020 and June 2025.
Index and fund figures come from Bitwise's own fact sheet, bitcoin's from Bitwise's quarterly market review. Full sourcing is in section 08.
01 The short answer
A crypto index fund sells one idea: you don't have to pick the winner, you own the market. In stocks that idea has decades of evidence behind it. In crypto, so far, it has eight years of evidence against it.
We took the longest live track record there is. The Bitwise 10 Large Cap Crypto Index holds the ten largest eligible crypto assets, weighted by free-float market cap and rebalanced monthly. The fund that tracks it, BITW, launched on 22 November 2017, so 2018 is its first full year. We put the index, the fund and plain bitcoin side by side for every year since.
Bitcoin won seven of the eight. The one exception was 2021, the year Ethereum, Solana and the rest of the market ran far ahead of BTC and the index returned 101.74% against bitcoin's 57.25%. That single year was not enough to catch up. Over the whole period bitcoin turned $1 into $6.25 and the index turned it into $3.30.
The gap did not come from one bad stretch. It built up almost every year, in bull markets and bear markets alike. The rest of this report shows where it came from, when the basket did win, and what would have to change for it to win again.
02 Year by year
● Bitcoin · ● Bitwise 10 index · ● BITW NAV
Sources: BITW fact sheet (index and fund NAV, as of 31 Aug 2026) and Bitwise Crypto Market Review Q1 2026 (bitcoin). Calendar years 2018 to 2025. Download the yearly returns (CSV).
The pattern holds in both directions. When the market rose, bitcoin usually rose more: its lead was 43.4 points in 2019, 23.5 in 2023 and 19.8 in 2024. When the market fell, bitcoin fell less, by 6.1 points in 2018, 3.7 in 2022 and 3.8 in 2025.
2020 is the year people remember as proof that the basket works, because the index nearly quadrupled. Bitcoin still finished 13.3 points ahead.
2026 is not over, so it is not in the chart. Through 30 September the index was down 6.2% and bitcoin about 4.6%, after a first half in which both lost roughly a third and a third quarter in which the index gained 46.39%.
03 Growth of $10,000
● Bitcoin · ● Bitwise 10 index · ● BITW NAV
Chained from the calendar-year returns in section 02. Sources: BITW fact sheet and Bitwise Crypto Market Review Q1 2026. End of 2017 to end of 2025. Terminal values are the chained paths rounded to the nearest dollar: $62,455, $33,016 and $28,329.
The three lines move together, which is the correlation from section 04 made visible. What separates them is a few points a year, compounding. By the end of 2025 that had become a gap of $29,439 between bitcoin and the index, and a further $4,687 between the index and the fund.
Starting later does not rescue the basket. We ran the same comparison from the first day of every year from 2018 to 2025, held to 30 September 2026. Bitcoin finished ahead from all eight starting points, including 2021, the year the index won. An investor who bought both on 1 January 2021 was up about 186% in bitcoin and 158% in the index.
Extended to 30 September 2026, the original $10,000 stands at roughly $59,600 in bitcoin and $30,970 in the index.
04 Risk: the basket did not soften the falls
The usual defence of an index is that it gives up some upside to protect you on the downside. Ten assets should be steadier than one. That is not what happened.
There were three losing calendar years in the sample, and the index lost more than bitcoin in each of them. In 2018 it fell 79.77% against bitcoin's 73.71%. In 2022 it fell 67.56% against 63.91%. In 2025 it fell 10.09% against 6.26%.
The reason is simple once you look at what sits beside bitcoin in the basket. Large altcoins are not a different asset class. They are a more volatile version of the same one. When bitcoin drops 60%, they tend to drop 70% or 80%, so adding them to bitcoin raises the drawdown instead of lowering it.
The correlation numbers say the same thing. Bitwise reports a 90-day rolling correlation of 0.99 between its index and bitcoin as of 31 March 2026, and an average daily correlation of 0.86 over the year to 31 August 2026. Diversification needs assets that move differently. These mostly do not.
WHAT THIS MEANS
If your reason for buying a crypto index fund is a smoother ride than bitcoin, the 2018 to 2025 record does not support it. The basket was the rougher ride in every down year.
05 Why the index lags
Three things explain most of the gap, and none of them is bad luck.
It is three quarters bitcoin. A cap-weighted top 10 cannot drift far from its largest member. Whatever the index does differently from bitcoin has to come from the other quarter of the basket.
The other quarter was a few winners and a lot of losers. The table shows the index as Bitwise reported it on 31 March 2026, with each asset's return over the previous five years. Solana and XRP did brilliantly. They also carried weights of 2.57% and 4.50%. Five of the smaller names lost between 69% and 97%.
| Asset | Index weight, % | 5-year return, % |
|---|---|---|
| Bitcoin (BTC) | 77.11 | 14.47 |
| Ethereum (ETH) | 14.22 | 8.37 |
| XRP | 4.50 | 131.01 |
| Solana (SOL) | 2.57 | 321.66 |
| Cardano (ADA) | 0.50 | −79.71 |
| Chainlink (LINK) | 0.34 | −70.49 |
| Litecoin (LTC) | 0.23 | −72.88 |
| Avalanche (AVAX) | 0.21 | −69.01 |
| Polkadot (DOT) | 0.12 | −96.56 |
| Bitwise 10 index | 100 | −0.55 |
Source: Bitwise Crypto Market Review Q1 2026, data as of 31 March 2026. Sui, the tenth holding at 0.19%, had no five-year history.
Over those five years bitcoin gained 14.47% and the index lost 0.55%, even though it held two assets that tripled and quadrupled.
The rules buy high and sell low at the bottom of the list. An asset only enters a top 10 after its market cap has already grown enough to get there. It leaves after it has shrunk enough to fall out. So the index picks up names near the end of their run and holds them through the decline. The churn is real: between 31 March and 30 September 2026 four of the ten slots changed, with Litecoin, Avalanche, Sui and Polkadot out and Zcash, Hyperliquid, Stellar and Uniswap in.
In a stock index the tail does not matter much, because the 400th company in the S&P 500 is still a profitable business. In crypto the tail is where the damage is.
06 The fund is not the index
Everything above compares bitcoin with an index, and nobody can buy an index. What investors actually held was BITW, and BITW did worse than the benchmark it tracks in two separate ways.
Fees. Before its exchange listing the fund's expense ratio ran close to 2.5% a year: 2.48% in 2019, 2.38% in 2020 and 2.51% in 2021, according to its annual report. The fund's NAV beat the index only once, in 2018, by 0.4 points. In the other seven years it trailed by between 0.8 and 6.6 points, and the average across all eight was 3.6 points a year. Compounded, that is the difference between $33,016 and $28,329 on the original $10,000.
The discount. From December 2020 the shares traded over the counter with no way to create or redeem them, so the price floated away from the value of the coins inside. Bitwise's own quarterly filing puts the average discount to NAV at 16.43% between 9 December 2020 and 30 June 2025. Someone who bought at a premium in early 2021 had a very different decade from the one the NAV describes. Yahoo Finance's annual return table shows the share price down 36.83% in 2021, a year in which the fund's NAV rose 95.17%.
Both problems are now largely fixed. BITW listed on NYSE Arca on 9 December 2025 as an exchange-traded product with a 0.75% fee. From the listing to 31 August 2026 the NAV returned −16.29% against −15.82% for the index, and the market price −16.65%. That is a gap of less than half a point.
WORTH KNOWING
The wrapper cost holders about as much as the basket did in some years. That part of the story is over. The index's own lag against bitcoin, covered in sections 02 to 05, is not a wrapper problem and a cheaper fee does not fix it.
07 When the index wins
It won once, and it won big. In 2021 the index returned 101.74% and bitcoin 57.25%, a gap of 44.5 points in the basket's favour. No other year in the sample comes close to that margin in either direction except 2019, when bitcoin led by 43.4 points.
What made 2021 different was breadth. Money moved out of bitcoin and into everything else at once, and bitcoin's share of the total market fell for most of the year. That is the textbook altcoin season, and it is the one environment where holding the other nine pays.
So the honest way to describe a cap-weighted crypto index is this: it is a bitcoin position with a small, permanent bet on altcoin season attached. In a year when that season arrives, the bet pays roughly what 2021 paid. In the years it does not, the bet costs a few points, and those years have been seven out of eight.
Three things could change the picture.
- A long stretch of falling bitcoin dominance. One year was not enough. Two or three in a row would close most of the gap.
- Different weighting. Everything here is about a cap-weighted top 10. An equal-weight basket such as CI10 holds 10% in each name, so it behaves far less like bitcoin. That should mean bigger wins in a 2021 and bigger losses in a 2022. We do not have eight years of live history to test it, and we will not pretend a backtest is the same thing.
- Different membership rules. The buy-high problem in section 05 comes from the top-N rule itself. Baskets built on sectors or fixed lists do not have it. You can build and track your own to see how a rule behaves before trusting it.
None of this says an index fund is the wrong tool. It says what the tool has delivered so far: bitcoin-like risk, somewhat less than bitcoin's return, and one very good year.
08 Methodology and data
What we compared. Bitcoin spot, the Bitwise 10 Large Cap Crypto Index, and the NAV of the Bitwise 10 Crypto Index ETF (BITW). We chose this index because it has the longest live record of any investable crypto basket: the fund has tracked it since 22 November 2017.
Period. Eight full calendar years, 2018 to 2025, plus 2026 through 30 September.
Where each number comes from.
| Series | Source | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Index and fund NAV, calendar years 2018 to 2025 | BITW fact sheet, as of 31 August 2026 | Index returns carry no fees. NAV is net of fund expenses. |
| Bitcoin, calendar years 2018 to 2025 | Bitwise Crypto Market Review Q1 2026, p.16 | Spot price, Bloomberg data. |
| Index, 2026 to 30 September | Cointelegraph on the Bitwise Q4 2026 review | −6.2% as reported. It matches the quarterly figures Bitwise published (−24.25%, −15.4%, +46.39%). |
| Bitcoin, 2026 to 30 September | Our estimate | About −4.6%. See below. |
| Weights, correlations, five-year returns | The two Bitwise documents above | Dates are given next to each figure. |
| Holdings on 30 September 2026 | BITW Form 10-Q |
What we calculated ourselves. The $10,000 paths, the compound annual returns, the entry-year comparison and the average NAV lag are all chained from the calendar-year returns above. Nothing in this report uses daily data.
The one estimate. Bitwise has not published a 2026 year-to-date figure for bitcoin that we could open. We derived it from two prices: $67,805 on 31 March 2026 after a 22.55% first-quarter fall (Bitwise review), which implies about $87,547 at the end of 2025, and about $83,557 on 30 September 2026, the fair value per coin in the fund's 10-Q. The two prices come from different sources, so treat −4.6% as accurate to within a point or so. It does not affect any of the 2018 to 2025 findings.
Limits.
- One index. Other benchmarks with different rules, such as CoinDesk 20 or the Nasdaq CME Crypto Index, are younger and may behave differently. Our benchmark report compares their rules.
- Calendar years hide what happens inside them. We make no claim here about maximum drawdown or volatility measured daily.
- Eight years is three bear markets and two bull markets. It is a record, not a law.
- Cryptoindex.ai's own indices are live display baskets with a short history. They are not part of this study.
This report is information, not investment advice.
09 FAQ
Do crypto index funds beat bitcoin? Not so far. From 2018 to 2025 bitcoin outperformed the Bitwise 10 Large Cap Crypto Index in 7 of 8 calendar years and compounded at 25.7% a year against 16.1% for the index.
Bitwise 10 vs bitcoin: which did better? Bitcoin. $10,000 invested at the end of 2017 grew to $62,455 in bitcoin and $33,016 in the Bitwise 10 index by the end of 2025. The BITW fund's NAV reached $28,329.
Is a crypto index fund less risky than bitcoin? The record says no. In each losing year of the sample (2018, 2022 and 2025) the index fell further than bitcoin. Its correlation with bitcoin was 0.99 on a 90-day basis in March 2026.
When did a crypto index last outperform bitcoin? In 2021, when the Bitwise 10 index returned 101.74% and bitcoin 57.25%. It was a year of falling bitcoin dominance and a broad altcoin rally.
How much of a crypto index fund is bitcoin? About three quarters in a cap-weighted top 10. Bitcoin was 76.25% of BITW on 31 August 2026, Ethereum 14.43%, and the six smallest holdings 2.26% combined.
Why did BITW trail its own index? Fees and structure. Its expense ratio was close to 2.5% before December 2025, and its NAV lagged the index by 3.6 points a year on average. Its shares also traded at an average 16.43% discount to NAV from December 2020 to June 2025. Since listing on NYSE Arca with a 0.75% fee, the gap has been under half a point.
Is a crypto index fund worth it? It depends on what you want from it. If you want exposure to more than bitcoin without choosing coins, it does that. If you expect it to beat bitcoin or fall less in a crash, eight years of data say it has done neither.
